When we lose a pet, we lose a part of ourselves: It is one of the hardest things that we go through. Our pets are precious and nobody wants to see one lost or hurt. Ring Doorbell knows this, and wants to exploit these feelings in a Superbowl ad for their new AI feature, Search Party. I will analyze this ad through the lenses of Althusser’s State Ideological Apparatuses and Foucault’s Panopticism, explaining why companies want you to give into AI usage as well as how the government is surveilling and controlling its population.
The advertisement in question begins with narration: “Pets are family,” while iPhone footage of a young girl and her dog plays. It continues by citing that 10 million pets go missing every year, cutting to footage of the young girl holding back tears as her father hangs a “Missing Dog” poster. The poster then morphs into different dogs in different areas, and the narrator explains that the tactics for finding missing animals haven't changed in years… until now. Thanks to Ring camera’s new AI feature, “Search Party,” you can now supply a photo of your dog and have Ring’s backlog of camera footage searched for your pet. As footage of the little girl reuniting with her lost dog plays, the narrator claims that since launch, more than a dog a day has been reunited with their families.
“Be a hero in your neighborhood. Join Search Party. Available to everyone, for free, right now. Join the neighborhood at ring.com.”
…Right.
We all love our pets. We can all empathize with the feeling of losing an animal. However, within the sentimental wrapping, this technology poses serious privacy and surveillance issues. Firstly, this ad wants you to associate AI with happy moments of families finding their lost furry friends. It’s evident that artificial intelligence is the media’s new favorite toy: 22% of the Superbowl ads this year were for AI programs (15 out of 66) and even more used AI in their creation. The popularity of this technology ignores its threat to the environment and thousands of jobs as we know them.
I will argue that due to the huge levels of investment in AI, media companies need to push it as an ideological truth in order to gain from it. The first media studies scholar we need to look at is Louis Althusser. Building on Marx’s idea of the State Apparatus (“the state is a machine of repression”), Althusser coined the terms Repressive and Ideological State Apparatuses. Althusser explains that ideology is subconscious, thus is shown in what you do, not what you say. He posits that ideology is characterized by naturalness and normalcy, present in all the assumptions we take for granted at any given moment. He goes on to state that ideology is created by the state, baked into our media and institutions in a way that subtly upholds a status quo. This status quo is then enforced by Ideological State Apparatuses.
(Chart differentiating RSA's and ISA's)
Althusser believes that repressive state apparatuses (police, military, courts, prisons – organized groups that function by violence) are not what keep most of us in line. Rather, ideology keeps us in line, and RSA are a last resort. Ideological state apparatuses are far more prevalent, and we willingly function within this system (no force needed). ISA’s exist in our media, politics, education, and religious spaces. Any powerful institution can and will exercise ideological control over its citizens. The government needs ISA’s because the potentially disruptive in society (any and all citizens) need to be controlled. Without using outright force, many can be kept complacent through media and institutional control.
(Excerpts from "Is artificial intelligence becoming too big to fail?")
Due to this level of monetary pressure, AI is ingrained into our media out of capitalistic necessity. AI is a huge change to our culture economically, and it is one that can be handled ideologically. Through marketing such as Ring’s Search Party missing pet feature, the masses can become comfortable with this new status quo.
Another text that the Ring ad reminds me of is Michel Foucault’s “Panopticism.” You may have heard this metaphor and seen the accompanying image: Foucault describes prisoners in a panopticon. The setup includes cells along the walls of a huge circular room and a tower in the center where the guards keep watch. The guards cannot be seen by the prisoners, and the guards have a visual of every cell at all times. This setup makes it so even if the guards aren’t looking at any given prisoner, they could be, creating a constant surveillance (even if the surveillance is imagined).
Foucault’s big idea here is that there is power in seeing: those who see have the power, while those who are looked at are at a disadvantage. To connect to Althusser’s ideas, the panopticon is read as a metaphor for Ideological State Apparatuses. Intangible and ever-present, we are being watched by security cameras and the phones in our pockets at all times. Even if it is subconscious, we act within the status quo due to this surveillance. In fact, we willingly update the panopticon with our posts on social media, and less directly, with data sharing between companies and institutions. Now, with AI technologies such as Ring’s Search Party, the panopticon grows ever stronger.




Comments
Post a Comment