Which post is more likely to make you stop and consider purchasing an item: the left or right?
(Paid ad from the fashion brand Cider, original content from Tunnel Vision)
If you answered right, you are in agreement with the brand Tunnel Vision’s consumer base.
As emphasized in my last post, Tunnel Vision’s anti-capitalist business model focuses their funds towards equal pay to their employees and ethically run warehouses. Because of this, Tunnel Vision has not run any paid ad campaigns on the Meta Ad Library (which lists active and past ads across Facebook and Instagram). Their unique method of relying on user generated content and organic reach means that any marketing campaigns from the brand are nontraditional and rare.
Mutual Aid Mega Sale
Tunnel Vision’s “Mutual Aid Mega Sale” was a week-long campaign in which the brand’s staff were taking time off to do volunteer work. For a week starting March 17, every item on Tunnel Vision’s website was 50% off. Almost all of Tunnel Vision’s campaigns are along similar lines: short-term, drastically deep discounts announced in a single post. This most recent discount, as shown in the screenshot above, aims to “keep sales coming in while we are doing volunteer work.”
There are two comments on their post, shown above, both of which are positive. One praises the brand’s mission and expresses enthusiastic support, while the other jokingly asks for a position at their company and offers to move to California for it. While showing a lack of engagement, these two comments also display strong passion from dedicated fans of the brand.
I noticed that this campaign announcement only exists on Instagram, and Tunnel Vision hasn’t posted on TikTok since the 10th of March. Instead, much of the brand discussion on TikTok happens on Madeline Pendleton’s personal profile. The graph below includes statistics from all over the internet, including from Tunnel Vision’s official accounts as well as discussions happening on other pages.
(Graph generated by Gemini)
Surprisingly, Tunnel Vision’s statistics show that their March 17 announcement of their 50% Mega Sale had little impact on their access, engagement, and passion. Instead, the peaks in this chart represent TikTok/reel posts that spur discussion on their ethical mission.
The first peak, where access exceeds both passion and engagement, falls on March 6. This corresponds with a TikTok giving fans a preview of their Spring collection. Word-of-mouth was high and driven by excitement over new designs and sizing inclusivity (5XL+ availability). The next peak is only a couple of days before their Mega Sale announcement, and corresponds with a matching TikTok and Instagram reel. The video screenshotted and linked below is of Madeline Pendleton rebutting common claims about their brand, and the caption points users to their newly released Sedex report. Between March 20-22, these videos gained traction, increasing all three of the brand’s metrics.
This information tells us that campaigns, even nontraditional ones, do not work as well as simply discussing the brand’s mission. Evidently, Tunnel Vision’s mission is their biggest strength to set them apart from competitors and increase their social media statistics.
SWOT Analysis
Given our exploration of Tunnel Vision’s online presence, marketing strategy, and public perception, it is time to analyze their strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats.
Strengths:
Tunnel Vision has several strengths that make them unique and drive their social media strategy. Firstly, their radical labor model in which all employees get equal pay is a highly marketable differentiation that makes their customers feel good about purchasing from them. Their strong mission of ethical, sustainable fashion for all sizes is another strong advantage. Size-inclusive alternative fashion is hard to come by, and Tunnel Vision is always striving to expand their sizing (most designs actually go up to 7XL). Their last big strength is their strong community: because their founder has a massive TikTok presence, their biggest marketing ROI comes from Madeline’s behind-the-scenes or educational content. Their fans are attracted to the brand's nostalgic, punk, and goth aesthetics as well as their paradigm shifting business practices.
(Screenshot showing Pendleton's 1.6M TikTok followers)
Weaknesses:
The brand’s weaknesses revolve around the quality of their products and the often polarizing discussions facilitated by their founder. A recurring criticism on platforms such as Reddit is the discrepancy between the “ethical” pricepoint and the actual garment durability. Tunnel Vision’s prices are high, and while they are claimed to reflect their sustainable production process, many customers report polyester items that fall apart quickly. These customers also complain about long delivery periods after purchase, which is explained by their ethical production process taking much longer than other brands. Another contradiction that contributes to Tunnel Vision’s weakness is their hesitancy to share any third-party ethical certifications. In the past, customers have asked to see certifications from groups like Fair Trade or B Corp, but the brand has avoided publicizing any such documents. However, on March 15, Tunnel Vision did release a Sedex report, finally providing proof for their claims of an ethical international supply chain. Lastly, Pendleton’s tendency to use her personal TikTok as a vessel for discussion about the brand, especially amidst controversy, can cause polarization of possible customers or even social media dogpiling.
(screenshot from Pendleton's personal TikTok)
Opportunities:
Firstly, Tunnel Vision’s position as an alternative brand attracts thrifty customers. An opportunity to further their ethical mission would be to start a resale program. If customers were able to send in their old Tunnel Vision items to be washed and resold, it could foster an even stronger community around their anti-capitalist and pro-environment goals. There is a reasonably high demand for second-hand Tunnel Vision products across platforms like Depop and Vinted, so building a program to facilitate this phenomenon could be beneficial. Another opportunity that Tunnel Vision has started to address is their supply chain traceability. The recent Sedex report was a huge step in the right direction, but by implementing regular transparency checks would increase the brand’s credibility and rebuild trust with skeptical buyers. Lastly, due to the brand’s strong community and nostalgia driven designs, an opportunity for the brand is a temporary pop-up event. Tunnel Vision could open a physical store in order to generate hype as well as allow customers to touch the items before purchasing, easing concerns about quality.
(Vintage section of TV's website)
Threats:
Tunnel Vision’s threats are economic and social. Firstly, customers are much less likely to spend money on expensive clothing in the current economy. Consumers may see such expensive, intricate clothing as a luxury they can no longer afford, and turn to cheaper, less ethical brands. Competitors like SHEIN and Temu often replicate Tunnel Vision’s designs and sell them at a much lower price point. Another threat to the brand is its dependency on social media. Yes, what is a great strength for this brand could also be their downfall. While the level of organic growth and earned media that Tunnel Vision receives is impressive, algorithms always change, and it is risky to rely on posts going viral for exposure.
(Screenshot showing TV's inconsistent view counts on TikTok)
Social Media Recommendations
I believe that Tunnel Vision’s anti-capitalist approach to marketing fits with their brand’s mission perfectly, and I would not ask them to change it. This tactic works so well because paid ads are often viewed as corporate or hollow by their audience of alternative Gen Z-ers. This audience is more likely to engage with a brand that they perceive as countercultural or underground. This being said, Tunnel Vision can definitely ramp up their efforts in terms of user-generated content and organic reach on social media.
(TV's stats once they revamp their social media strategy) (image source)
Firstly, to address Tunnel Visions weaknesses in transparency and product quality, a few strategy shifts could go a long way. One of the largest issues that consumers have with Tunnel Vision is their insistence on their ethical workplace and sustainable supply chain without continued verification. Instead of Madeline creating multi-part video series explaining their ethics with words, it would be more effective and trustworthy to release proof of her claims. Beyond releasing proof, a permanent “Transparency” or “Ethics” section of their socials (such as a story highlight or a link in their bio) would prove that they are dedicated to their mission and have nothing to hide. Some information in this transparency section should include names and locations of their international partners, owning up to product mistakes/showing how they will be fixed, and testimony from warehouse staff or even a redacted pay stub. These documents would be a more solid rebuttal to the brand’s detractors or unhappy customers and dissuade any claims of green-washing.
(Comment on this post about TV's first sedex report)
Another issue that could be addressed through a new social media strategy is Tunnel Vision’s over dependence on Madeline Pendleton as a creator. While valuable as a strong leader and figurehead, Pendleton has faced their fair share of controversy and has struggled convincing the internet of their good intentions. It would be worthwhile to shift focus away from Pendleton and have new faces on the feed. The Tunnel Vision TikTok, underutilized by Pendleton in favor of their personal TikTok, could be contributed to by a wider array of employees. By featuring stories or behind-the-scenes content from a variety of workers instead of Pendleton alone, the brand could diversify their content while also reinforcing their no-boss structure.
Campaign Idea: Monthly Community Highlight
To energize Tunnel Vision’s groundswell and optimize their reach, engagement, and passion, they should launch a campaign highlighting the brand’s community. My idea involves prompting the community on their TikTok and Instagram with a different question every month. Examples could be “How do you style your TV jewelry?" or “What designs do you want to see in our next drop?”. After the month is up, the brand would feature their favorite responses on Instagram and TikTok, giving away store credit or an item of the month.
(Tunnel Vision giveaway from last year)
These posts would encourage their audience to create content about and of the brand, expanding their reach and encouraging engagement. The possible reward of store credit or a free item is reasonable, as Tunnel Vision has held giveaways in the past. However, their giveaways only require that you follow them and leave a comment on a post. I believe that adding the content creation element would allow for further access for the brand and encourage a wider perspective on the brand. As it stands, Tunnel Vision’s reposts to their main feed all feature established influencers, which feels a little less authentic than the brand’s mission suggests. By asking the wider community to create content and then actually repost and reward that content, Tunnel Vision could uplift the voices of community activists, niche artists, and, most importantly, regular customers who embody the brand's values.
(Example of earned media that TV can utilize in their social media strategy)
To Conclude…
Tunnel Vision is a unique brand with a valuable perspective on the workplace and the fashion industry. By using these aspects of their brand to their advantage, they have managed to attract a high level of organic reach, bolstering their engagement and passion. However, by tweaking their social media strategy and employing stronger campaigns, the brand could reach even bigger levels of success, against all odds.
(Image from Tunnel Vision's Instagram)
What do you think about Tunnel Vision? Are their ethical and sustainability promises impossible to uphold in this economy, or can a social media re-vamp save them from succumbing to fast fashion competitors?
Thank you for reading!
Comments
Post a Comment